* Defined in the report as "an abortion provider in Nebraska and Maryland” and along with numerous references to Germantown, Maryland, is believed to be LeRoy Carhart
PRESS RELEASE by Panel Chairman, Congresswoman Marsha Blackburn
PANEL REPORT has Immediate effect: House Speaker Paul Ryan promises to defund Planned Parenthood
READ the full U.S. House Select Investigative Panel Report (link)
REPORT INCLUDES horrific 4 pages of photo evidence (link) of the Reality of Late-term Abortion **WARNING GRAPHIC** "America will not reject abortion until America sees abortion." ~Father Frank Pavone
READ Carhart’s Response to Select Panel Subpoena (link); HIGHLIGHTS: 1) Claims has never "been involved in any medical practice litigation, threatened or actual”; 2) Further claims “No documents or communications exist relative to the donation or sale of fetal tissue.” However, when later asked to provide “All communications and documents sufficient to show whether any current and former personnel of [his] had responsibilties which include[d] procuring, researching, storing, or packaging for donation, sale, or transport of any fetal tissue,” he states “Any documents responsive to this request will be produced”; 3) While not providing any specific personal evidence of such, Carhart maintains he exists under a "heightened risk [of] harassment, violence, intimidation, and harm” and experiences “very real threats to [his] personal safety and security”; 4) Carhart explains that he is “particularly concerned” by his belief that ”organizations linked to Scott Roder [George Tiller’s murderer currently serving a life sentence in prison]…[have] directly initiated complaints against [him] with the Maryland Board of Physicians."
Excerpt from Final Report Chapter VII - Case Studies of Late-Term Abortion Clinics (pp. 281-283)
Abortion clinics and hospitals typically use one of two methods when performing abortions in the second and third trimesters of pregnancy—dilatation and evacuation (D&E) or induction. Both of these procedures require a patient’s cervix to be dilated over a period of hours to days prior to the actual procedure. During that dilation process, an infant can be delivered spontaneously.765 If the infant has not been administered feticide—typically intracardiac potassium chloride injection (KCl) or intrafetal/intra-amniotic digoxin injection— or if the feticide fails, infants are sometimes born alive. While infants are not likely to be born alive during the D&E procedure, which entails dismembering and removing the infant and the placenta with forceps, infants have been born alive following the induction process in an induction abortion.
The business practices and procedures of late-term clinics implicate numerous legal and ethical concerns. When human infants are born alive in late-term abortion clinics or hospitals, abortion providers are obligated to ensure that these infants are afforded all of the protections guaranteed by federal and state law.
According to the Centers for Disease Control, between 2003 and 2014, 588 reported infant deaths included a code indicating that a cause of death was “termination of pregnancy, affecting fetus and newborn.” At least 143 of these deaths could definitively be classified as involving an induced abortion; however, the CDC acknowledges that this could be an underestimate.
The Panel’s Investigation into the Clinic in Maryland
[T]he Panel decided to interview several of the employees of the clinic in Maryland in order to investigate the above-mentioned items. In the interviews, when questioned on when [Abortion Doctor #1] thinks viability occurs, the employees stated 27 weeks. [Clinic Worker #1] stated that up to 27 weeks, the woman does not need to provide a justification for the abortion, as shown in the following excerpt from the transcript:
Q. Can I just, the 20- to 27-week range, which is about 50 percent of your practice, so do the women have to provide any justification for the abortion during that period of time from 20 to 27 weeks?
A. No, ma’am.
Q. So it's only after 27 weeks?
In addition to the concerns that purely elective, post-viability abortions are taking place, there have been several medical complications that have occurred at the clinic, under the watch of [Abortion Doctor #1]. Since December 2010, 9 women have been transferred to a nearby hospital due to complications from an abortion at this clinic, with 7 of them being emergency transports. The most alarming factor is that 5 of the 9 transfers have occurred since December 2015. In April 2016, the Panel met with a confidential informant, a former employee of the clinic, who claimed that [Abortion Doctor #1] is not fit to practice due to arthritis in his hands. (emphasis added)
December 29th 2016...3:49am...
Carhart’s Abortion Patient Required to Return to Clinic, Wrapped in Sheet, leaves 98 minutes later
December 30th 2016...3:56am…
Another Patient Arrives at Clinic for Further Treatment, leaves…??...
Thursday, December 29th - Appearing to be clutching a sheet of cloth or plastic around her waist, LeRoy Carhart’s late-term abortion patient 'straddle walked' into Germantown Reproductive Health Services in the early morning hours. In addition to Carhart and his wife, three other staff members were present for the patient’s return. All had left the building by 5:30 AM. Only eight months ago Carhart’s 9th ambulance patient was taken to the hospital from this clinic [news story, video link].
It should be noted that these incidents ocurred one day before and on the first court date in the negligence and malpractice suit brought against both LeRoy Carhart and Germantown Reproductive Health Services by a patient (see Devine v Carhart links below).
Devine v Carhart; First Court Date, December 30, 2016
Circuit Court for Montgomery County - Civil System, Case Number: 425378V
Dates discussed at December 30, 2016 Scheduling hearing:
- Jury Trial Date: September 5 - 15, 2017 (9 days)
- Pre-trial Hearing: August 11, 2017 1:30pm
- Pre-trial Statements: August 2, 2017
- Meeting of Counsel: July 25, 2017
- Motion(s) Cutoff Date: July 12, 2017
- Discovery Deadline: July 7, 2017
- Defense Expert(s) Identification Date: March 1, 2017
- Plaintiff’s Expert(s) Identification Date: January 13, 2017
NOTE: Official Dates to be Posted by Montgomery County Circuit Court
SEE Carhart Sued for Negligence and Malpractice in Germantown Late-Term Abortion for more information about the lawsuit.
December 11, 2016, the Return of LeRoy Carhart to Germantown, Maryland
9th Carhart Patient Taken Away by Ambulance April 4th!!
>3rd in 15 days!<
Emergency Medical Services arrive 12:33pm, leave 12:48pm
Ambulance Leaves with “hemoraging” Patient
>>>Operation Rescue (link): "6 in 5 Months! Carhart’s Hemorrhaging Late-Term Abortion Patient Transported to Hospital”
8th CARHART PATIENT TAKEN AWAY BY AMBULANCE March 30th
- 7th TRANSPORTED TO LOCAL HOSPITAL ONLY 10 DAYS EARLIER
- 2nd in March 2016 alone (!!)
With no flashing lights or sirens, a ‘private’ ambulance arrives at LeRoy Carhart’s Germantown Late-term abortion clinic at 10:24am Wednesday March 30th, where his latest patient is seen taken away with IV intact.
>>>Operation Rescue (link): "Menace Continues: Another Carhart Late-term Abortion Patient Rushed Away by Ambulance”
7th PATIENT TAKEN AWAY BY AMBLANCE MARCH 20, 2016
Sunday March 20, 2016 6:00pm: the 7th (and young) patient of LeRoy Carhart is taken to a local hospital via ambulance from his Germantown MD clinic since opening in December 2010. Fire & Rescue calls indicate seriousness of the situation; “ALS 1, Heart Problems.”
4 Patients in 4 Consecutive Months
>>>For the past 4 months; December 2015, January 2016, February 2016 (in Nebraska), and now March 2016, LeRoy Carhart has sent women to the hospital.<<<
At Johns Hopkins University Carhart Publicly Declares: “Virtually Nobody is Happy When They Leave Our Clinic…"
On February 3rd 2016, LeRoy Carhart spoke at the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine in Baltimore, MD to a room of prospective future abortionists. A person in attendance observed; the abortionist "seemed slow and lethargic" during their conversation. "Carhart seemed to me to be sickly, exhausted and of ill health and stamina. His face had a droop to it and his expression and voice conveyed little emotion or liveliness . His voice seemed feeble, monotone and tired."
Dispite flying back and forth from Nebraska almost weekly and often works seven days a week, during the Hopkins event Carhart dening being exhausted. However the very next day, Feburary 4th, another one of his patients from Nebraska was sent to the hospital.
For details about the event at, "What would a late-term abortionist say to med students?” Listen to audio from the event here.
LifeSiteNews HEADLINE: "Late-term abortionist LeRoy Carhart sends fourth patient to hospital in four months: eyewitnesses"
GERMANTOWN, Maryland, March 22, 2016 (LifeSiteNews - link) -- Pro-life activists say Dr. Leroy Carhart's late-term abortion clinic in Maryland sent another patient to the hospital on Sunday.
This Sunday's ambulance evacuation of an underage girl to Shady Grove Hospital is the fourth from Carhart's Nebraska and Maryland locations since December 2015.
According to video and a press release provided to LifeSiteNews by local pro-life activists, eyewitnesses say two emergency vehicles were sent to Carhart's clinic, Germantown Reproductive Health Services. An underage girl was then sent to a local hospital, marking what the Executive Director of Maryland Coalition for Life said in a statement was the seventh "documented" case of injury, in addition to one death, at the clinic since it opened in 2010.
In a phone conversation, a spokesperson for Germantown Reproductive Health Services declined to comment on the latest alleged evacuation. Spokespersons for Shady Grove Hospital did not respond to multiple requests for comment from LifeSiteNews as to whether the hospital had taken in the underage patient.
According to Andrew Glenn, executive director of Maryland Coalition for Life, "With this many medical emergencies happening so close together, the Board needs to immediately suspend LeRoy Carhart’s license while these unfortunate incidents are fully investigated. There have been 7 documented injuries and 1 death here in Germantown and 5 other serious cases from his Nebraska office."
"This man is a danger to women, and it is the responsibility of the State authorities to thoroughly examine the competency of this out of state doctor who is nearly 75. Germantown Pregnancy Choices will be filing a formal complaint to the Maryland Board of Physicians today to report the medical emergencies that occurred during the last four months."
Two of the other three recent ambulatory evacuations took place on December 15 and January 19 in Germantown. The fourth, on February 4, was in Nebraska, after Carhart spoke to medical students at Johns Hopkins University.
According to a recording of the presentation conducted by Students for Life of America and provided to LifeSiteNews, Carhart was asked about his health. The student also asked whether there were regulations limiting how many hours he could work to make sure his "patients are healthy."
"I guess I'm too old, too," Carhart joked in response. "There are a lot of things that some people come up with. I don't know where the exhaustion thing came from. Maybe I look tired to you today. I've been up since, what, 6:00 this morning. Still going."
"I don't think that I've ever been impaired because of sleep or exhaustion, or whatever. I fly into here, but I sleep the whole four hours on the airplane" to and from Nebraska. "We do spend long days..."
Johns Hopkins undergraduate student Andrew Guernsey, a former president of the on-campus pro-life group Voices for Life and a former LifeSiteNews intern, spoke to Carhart the evening he spoke at the university. According to Guernsey, the abortionist "seemed slow and lethargic" during their conversation.
"Carhart seemed to me to be sickly, exhausted and of ill health and stamina. His face had a droop to it and his expression and voice conveyed little emotion or liveliness . His voice seemed feeble, monotone and tired," Guernsey told LifeSiteNews.
Carhart is perhaps most infamous for, in addition to his late-term abortion career, killing 29-year old Jennifer Morbelli. Morbelli had gone to Carhart to end a 33-week pregnancy; her 2013 death resulted in an investigation of Carhart's practice.
>>SIXTH<< WOMAN TAKEN TO THE HOSPITAL BY AMBULANCE
7:46PM JANUARY 19, 2016. FOR THE SIXTH TIME SINCE 2013 LERORY CARHART SENDS WOMAN TO THE HOSPITAL BY AMBULANCE FROM HIS GERMANTOWN CLINIC!!
Carhart Hospitalizes Sixth Abortion Patient in Germantown, Maryland
January 22, 2016 By Operation Rescue - (link)
by Cheryl Sullenger
Germantown, MD – An ambulance transported a female patient of late-term abortionist LeRoy Carhart to a Germantown hospital on the evening of January 19, 2016, about a month after another similar incident that also resulted in emergency hospitalization of another of his patients.
Security camera footage obtained by Operation Rescue shows an ambulance arriving at Germantown Reproductive Health Services in Germantown, Maryland at approximately 7:46 p.m. according to the video time-stamp. Seven minutes later, emergency responders are seen leaving the late-term abortion facility with the injured women on a gurney.
Carhart and his wife, Mary Lou, are also seen exiting the abortion facility and leaving the parking lot immediately after the ambulance.
Carhart has not held hospital privileges anywhere, including Maryland, since 1982.
Carhart conducts abortions throughout all nine months of pregnancy at Germantown Reproductive Health Services where he has worked for the past five years. Carhart also operates his own abortion facility in Bellevue, Nebraska, where state law limits abortions to under 20 weeks.
A witness on the scene has told Operation Rescue that on January 19, Carhart saw 21 patients. Seven of those were risky late-term abortion deliveries.
The patient that was transported was said to have been the first patient to arrive for the day and the last to leave eleven hours later – long after everyone else had been released.
This is the sixth medical emergency that has resulted in the hospitalization of a Carhart abortion patient since he began working in Maryland five years ago. One of those incidents resulted in the death of Jennifer Morbelli, who succumbed on Feburary 7, 2012, to complications of a 33-week abortion. Even though Carhart was unable to be contacted as Morbelli’s condition worsened, which fatally delayed emergency Carhart was never held accountable.
Carhart was also involved in the death of another late-term abortion patient, Christin Gilbert, a 19-year old Down syndrome teen who died from complications to a botched third trimester abortion on January 13, 2005.
“When Carhart moved his late-term abortion business to Germantown, we predicted he would kill again, and that prediction came true. Now he has hospitalized two women within a month of each other and we do not know if either woman is alive or dead,” said Operation Rescue President Troy Newman. “Carhart is a dangerous abortionist that has maimed and killed enough. We urgently call on the Maryland Board of Physicians to step in and stop Carhart from practicing in Maryland before he kills again.”
Earlier this week, Operation Rescue named Carhart’s Germantown Reproductive Health Services as one of the six most dangerous abortion business in the U.S.
Very Young Carhart Patient Seen Clinging to Her Stuffed Animal After Late-Term Abortion Outside Clinic
Very young in appearance, a late-term abortion patient of LeRoy Carhart’s is seen sitting on the curb clinging to her stuffed animal outside his abortion clinic in Germantown, MD.
Later, Carhart and staff exit the clinic and offer the young girl a ride. During the entire time she was outside the clinic, the stuffed pink toy never left the young girl’s side. More about this incident can been seen at Gloria.TV
>>FIFTH<< CARHART PATIENT TAKEN AWAY BY AMBULANCE
On Tuesday December 15th 2015 for the FIFTH TIME SINCE 2013 an ambulance was called to Germantown Reproductive Health Services to take Carhart’s patient to a local hospital. In the pictures below, Carhart can be seen in his white lab coat escorting the patient out to the ambulance, and then climbing into the back before leaving the office park.
CHRONOLOGY OF CARHART's GERMANTOWN PATIENTS TAKEN TO HOSPITAL BY AMBULANCE
December 15, 2015 - FIFTH Carhart patient since 2013 leaves his clinic by ambulance
July 2, 2014 - FOURTH Carhart patient in 17 MONTHS taken away by ambulance
March 4, 2014 − THIRD Carhart patient taken by ambulance to hospital
November 26, 2013 − SECOND Carhart patient taken by ambulance to hospital
July 9, 2013 − FIRST Carhart patient taken by ambulance to hospital
February 7, 2013 - Jennifer Morbelli taken to local hospital by family members after not being able to contact Carhart and sadly DIES on the 5th day after the start of a 33-week Carhart abortion
>>MORE on this story from Operation Rescue (link), including full video of the event.
Marking 5 Years Of LeRoy Carhart in Germantown, Local Churches Hold Candle Light Procession and Vigil
LeRoy Carhart (now 74 years old) came to Germantown Maryland in December 2010. Since then more than 3,800 children have died here. The faithful who protest prayerfully and peacefully each week marked the solemn occasion on December 6, 2015 with a candle light procession to Germantown Reproductive Health Services. Outside the clinic the group of 100 people paused to ask God Almighty to end the scourge of late-term abortion in Germantown.
Abortion Myths BUSTED
Myth: We all have heard it say women have abortions because they want to, not because they are being pressured.
BUSTED: From Carhart’s Nebraska clinic - A young woman came out of Carhart’s and went to some prayer warriors standing on the sidewalk. She explained to them that she was being pressured into having an abortion by her mother. She was there to begin a medical abortion (RU486). When she was confronted and told to take the first pill, she said she just could not do it. So she left. They refused to give her the $400.00 back. The prayer warriors and sidewalk counselors then took the young lady to EPS for continual care and support. PRAISE GOD! Please continue to pray for her. She is still in danger of being forced to abort her child.
Clinic Workers Send Lurid Christmas Card, While Carhart Doubles Up Over Colorado Springs Shooting
The pro-life center located directly across from Carhart’s clinic, Germantown Pregnancy Choices, was recently mailed a “Christmas Card” from the workers at Carhart’s clinic, Germantown Reproductive Health Services. Not only is the imagery on the front of the card luridly tasteless (therefore not shown), the card also contained an audio CD of Christian Christmas songs such as Away in a Manger and O Holy Night. The inclusion of sacred Christmas music under the banner of “Happy Holidays From Germantown Reproductive Health Services” (shown below) is an absolute travesty. See more about this story from LifeSiteNews.
On November 30th, the Sunday after the tragic Colorado Springs shooting at a Planned Parenthood clinic, Carhart hired a second uniformed off duty Montgomery County Police officer at his clinic in Germantown. A uniformed officer has been present on Sundays, Mondays, Tuesdays and Wednesdays since February, 2012. It is unclear how long the second officer will be there.
“SAVED” - a Film That **WILL** Save Lives30 minute broadcast quality film is being made by Two Crown Productions to tell the gripping story of Germantown over the past 4 years. Entitled “SAVED”, the documentary is about the late-term abortions occurring in Germantown and the fruit of the community’s faithful response. Your help is needed to make this film a reality so it can be shared free of charge far and wide. Can you support this effort with any amount possible?
God Intervenes in the Life of an Unborn Child in Germantown!
Recently a woman, "Janice", arrived for a late-term abortion and spoke with a side-walk counselor before going into Carhart’s clinic. After being in his clinic she came out and talked again with a side-walk counselor who directed her to Germantown Pregnancy Choices (GPC).
Once inside GPC, Janice was able to share what brought her to Germantown from two states away. She was 26 weeks pregnant with her third child, had a full time job, and the baby's father was not in the picture. Nobody knew she was coming to abort. So when she received two phone calls that morning, they were a surprise and Janice knew that it was God's direct intervention in her life and the life of her unborn child.
One call was from a friend to say that she had a dream about Janice, and that she should not do what she was planning on doing. Then another call came this time from Janice’s Aunt saying she too had a dream and told her not to do what she was planning and if she did, she would die. Janice received the same message from both of these women: "Don't do it". But neither her friend nor her Aunt knew that she was going in for an abortion that day.
Janice was given information for a pregnancy center close to her Aunt's home so she can go in and get more information before she left for her home. Which she did. Janice is back home, keeping the baby and very happy.
God put all the pieces together: two women having dreams, women who decided to act on those dreams, a woman who was open to listening to others, and a family willing to help a relative through this pregnancy.
>>THANK YOU LORD FOR JANICE & THE GIFT OF HER CHILD!!
FROM THE FRONT LINES WITH 40 DAYS FOR LIFE:
"One day this week during my hour on Wisteria Drive in Germantown MD for the 40 Days for Life vigil, a high school student stopped to tell me that what we do is good work and that makes it a difference. Since he had seen us out there, he knew to refer his sister to us when she was considering an abortion. He was leaving school early that day because his sister had gone into labor with her son, Gabriel Isaiah! Praise God that our consistent pro-life presence out there impressed a young man and rescued an unborn child! What a great encouragement to all of us who come to Wisteria to pray and witness for life!"
Here is ANOTHER STORY from a 40 Days For Life church coordinator about their experience recently on Wisteria Drive while praying with members of a youth group. Yet another powerful example of how God is using your presence on the sidewalk to save lives.
“Praise God! The prayers of those young people blew me away! And then a lovely lady stopped by and gave the Youth group a set of T-shirts with the sonogram of an unborn child and told the youth group they were angels for being on the sidewalk. And she told them that a sign-carrying angel had caused her to reflect on her decision to have an abortion, and had caused her to CHANGE HER MIND. She now has a lovely three year old child. It was a very powerful message for me and the group to hear."
Not only did their presence on the sidewalk 3 years ago save a life, the mother is now involved in pro-life work and is being a voice for the unborn.
Say HELLO to ‘Javier Jesus’, BORN Wednesday August 20th, 2014.
After receiving a poor pre-natal diagnosis that would have lead to an almost certain death shortly after his birth, this little boy’s parents came to Carhart in Germantown at 28 weeks pregnant. After talking with the side-walk counselors the parents went to a specialist who also brought to them the same diagnosis. Courageously choosing to bring their son into the world instead of aborting him, his parents were expecting the worst. But God had other plans. Javier Jesus only needed minor abdominal surgery and he will be fine and healthy. No explanation except for God's direct intervention. Your prayers are being heard! The Mom is doing fine and both parents are extremely grateful.
JULY 2nd 2014, 11:59am; FOURTH (!!) WOMAN TAKEN TO HOSPITAL FROM CARHART’S GERMANTOWN CLINIC
Wednesday July 2nd, at 11:59AM the FOURTH Carhart patient in the past 17 MONTHS is taken to the hospital by ambulance from his clinic in Germantown, Maryland.
Minutes later a SECOND ambulance arrives with a Paramedic rushing inside the first ambulance.
3rd Woman in 13 Months Taken from Germantown Clinic to Local Hospital by Ambulance
Germantown, MD (Operation Rescue) – After little sleep and a heavy patient load, LeRoy Carhart sent another abortion patient to the hospital on March 4, 2014 for treatment of apparently life-threatening complications.
An ambulance arrived at about 4:00 p.m. in response for a call for emergency assistance. It transported a female patient to a local hospital. Carhart was not seen with his patient during the incident.
Due to a snowstorm, Carhart was unable to see women scheduled for multi-day late-term abortions as usual on Sunday. Carhart was seen by witnesses at the Germantown Reproductive Health Services abortion clinic between 5:00 and 11:00 p.m. on Monday then was back at the clinic 9:45 a.m. Tuesday morning where at least 16 abortion patients were seen.
March 4, 2014 − 3rd Carhart patient taken by ambulance to hospital
November 26, 2013 − 2nd Carhart patient taken by ambulance to hospital
July 9, 2013 − 1st Carhart patient taken by ambulance to hospital
February 7, 2013 - Jennifer Morbelli dies at local hospital after 33-week Carhart abortion
“It appears that Carhart was once again conducting surgeries on women in a fatigued state, as he is known to do. He brags of never taking a day off. At the age of 72, we believe he is endangering women with his irresponsible behavior, and this latest medical emergency in Germantown is more evidence of that,” said Troy Newman, President of Operation Rescue.
As far back as 1993, Carhart was ordered by the Nebraska Attorney General to stop “interrupting or delaying a surgical procedure including abortion due to or as a result of his exhaustion or fatigue.”
Medical emergencies at Carhart’s abortion facilities in Maryland and in Bellevue, Nebraska, have become more frequent in recent months, leading to concerns that he is unfit to continue practicing medicine.
Operation Rescue is in the process of filing a complaint with the Maryland Board of Physicians demanding an emergency suspension of Carhart’s medical license pending a full investigation into the recent rash of abortion injuries.
SOURCE: Operation Rescue
YES your presence in Germantown DOES makes a difference...Consider this!!
"While praying on Wisteria Drive during the 40 Days for Life Campaign, all of a sudden a young woman stood in front of us and simply said, "I just stopped by to say thank you for all you're doing." I hadn't seen her, but she had been driving by and pulled into the parking lot. (By the way, it was pouring!).
We then heard her story: She is a single mom with 4 children, and is 5 months pregnant with her 5th child. This past January, 2014 she had an appointment at Carhart's for an abortion on a Monday morning. The Friday (or Saturday) night before, she had driven by on Wisteria and she saw about 10 - 15 people holding signs and praying. At that point, she decided she could not go through with the abortion and cancelled her appointment.
This was a powerful testimony to me that the Lord is using our presence to save lives even if we never talk directly to anyone. Only God knows how many others have changed their minds just because we are here in Germantown.”